The comment fight over H-1B extensions is now on the record. As the public comment period closed Nov. 13, the University of Michigan, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, AILA, the American Immigration Council and employer groups urged DHS to keep the rule requiring USCIS to generally defer to its prior approval when the same employer and worker seek an extension on unchanged facts. Supporters of the change, including America First Legal, argued each petition should be examined on its own.
DHS's own numbers frame the stakes: about 6,044 additional Requests for Evidence a year, and a median initial decision time of 76 days with an RFE versus 12 days without one, among roughly 208,000 eligible petitions.
Why it matters for South Florida Malayalees (SFM) readers on H-1B and L-1 status: this remains a proposal — nothing has changed, and existing approvals stand. SFM's earlier report covered the comment period closing; keep documents consistent with your original petition and see the H-1B status-change checklist. This is general information, not legal advice. Flagged for human review: consequential immigration item.
Frequently asked questions
Does this change my H-1B extension today?
No. This is a proposed rule only. The current deference regulation stays in force unless and until DHS publishes a final rule and it takes effect.
What happens next?
DHS reviews the comments filed by Nov. 13 and decides whether to issue a final rule, revise the proposal, or drop it. No effective date has been announced.